Can you bake a cake in aluminum foil pan

While nothing beats a high-quality metal or ceramic cake pan, if you’re in a rush or are baking for a party, a disposable pan makes a lot of sense.

Can you bake cheesecake in an aluminum pan?

Absolutely, in fact, you can use disposable aluminum pans for any of your cake recipes.

You won’t have to wash the pan afterward.

You can simply serve, enjoy, and then dispose of the pan.

This is perfect if you’re going to a picnic, heading to a potluck dinner, or if you’re serving guests for a party and don’t have enough bakeware available.

There are some minor adjustments you’ll need to make when baking cheesecake or any other cake in an aluminum pan, which we’ll explain below.

Aluminum pans can cause sticking and burning, although it’s less of a problem with cheesecake.

Your cheesecake base will be made from Graham Crackers or similar biscuit ingredients, so it’s less likely to burn than a traditional cake where the batter is poured right in.

Still, to reduce the risk, you can line the bottom of the aluminum pan with some baking paper.

Cut the paper to shape with kitchen scissors, and then assemble the crust of your cheesecake.

This If You Care Parchment Baking Paper is made from unbleached paper coated in silicon, so it’s free of the toxic materials used in standard baking paper.

Avoid pans with bottoms that are significantly smaller than the top, because you’ll miss out on having all that fantastic base with every slice.

Aluminum foil pans are one of the most useful tools in the kitchen. Their versatility makes life a lot easier when used correctly.

You can bake in aluminum foil pans. However, it is recommended that you set them on a baking sheet before putting them into the oven to provide stability. Otherwise, the bendable nature of aluminum foil could cause a mess.

The rest of the article will cover a few common questions as well as provide a few ideas on when and when not to use aluminum foil pans.

Is It Necessary To Wash Disposable Aluminum Pans Before Using?

Even though the top part of some of the aluminum pans are covered with plastic, most are open and uncovered when you buy them, and all should be washed thoroughly before use. You just never know what they may have come in contact with between the manufacturing facility and the store from which they were purchased.

Is It Necessary To Grease The Bottom Of A Disposable Aluminum Pan?

It is necessary to grease the bottom and sides of a disposable aluminum pan before using it to bake any type of food to prevent the food from sticking to the pan. The most simple method is to spray the bottom and sides of the pan or pans with a baking spray.

Is It Safe To Freeze Food In A Disposable Aluminum Pan?

It is safe to freeze food in a disposable aluminum pan and is particularly handy when freezing foods such as casseroles that must be heated in the oven. Just remove the container from the freezer and give it time to thaw, either at room temperature or in the refrigerator, then reheat.

This is also useful when freezing things like brownies or cookies that may become damaged if simply placed into the freezer in a freezer bag. The aluminum pan provides a certain amount of protection from the brownies or cookies becoming crushed or broken in the freezer.

Pro Tip: Be sure, however, to cover the aluminum pan with a good freezer-quality aluminum foil or plastic wrap, or simply slide the pan into a freezer bag. It is always a good practice to double wrap foods for the freezer to protect them from freezer burn and to keep the food good for a longer period of time.

Is It Safe To Reuse Disposable Aluminum Pans?

It is safe to reuse disposable aluminum pans as long as you can get them thoroughly clean between uses. Some people do not reuse these pans because they are, after all, disposable, but they can be reused many times until they become damaged in some way.

Is It Safe To Put Disposable Aluminum Containers In The Oven?

It is safe to put disposable aluminum containers in the oven. In fact, they are made from food-grade aluminum, and that is what they are made for. There is no danger of the containers or the food being damaged by using them in the oven.

There are loaf pans made for baking breads, and there are heavy-duty large baking pans that are reinforced and made to bake that holiday turkey or ham, and many sizes in between for all those other baking needs like for brownies and casseroles.

Can I Bake A Cake In A Disposable Aluminum Pan?

Disposable aluminum pans are perfect for baking cakes, especially cakes that must be transported. They take away the risk of losing those nice stainless steel pans or expensive cake takers that we may or may not get back when taking food away from home.

Can I Bake Brownies In A Disposable Aluminum Pan?

Baking brownies is a good use for disposable aluminum pans, and the perfect size of 8 or 9-inch square pans are available for that particular purpose. Here again, this is especially handy if those brownies are going to be transported away from home so that you do not have to be concerned about bringing your pan home.

What Should I Not Bake In An Aluminum Pan?

There isn’t anything that cannot be baked in an aluminum pan. However, some foods react adversely to aluminum. Here are a few examples of things to watch for:

• When baking dishes made primarily with eggs, there can be a slight discoloration of the eggs around the edges where the eggs make contact with the pan.
• When baking potato dishes, potatoes can react adversely with aluminum and cause an unappetizing grayish color in the potatoes where they make contact with the aluminum pan.
• Lasagna and other dishes containing tomatoes, which are highly acidic, can react with the aluminum in disposable pans. This should not be an issue unless you are using one of the smaller, thinner aluminum pans, and the acidic reaction may result in holes in the pan.

When to Use Aluminum Foil Pans

Aluminum foil pans are extremely useful in the kitchen for a variety of reasons, including:

1. For those times of heavy baking when you do not have enough baking pans
2. For ease of cleaning for messy jobs like lasagna
3. For taking to a pot-luck meal to avoid being concerned about remembering to get your pans
4. To make a double batch and freeze a portion
5. To give as gifts.

1. When You Do Not Have Enough Baking Pans

When you keep a supply of disposable aluminum pans on hand, they are there to save the day when you are baking more than usual and do not have enough regular pans to bake what you are making.

I always keep a few aluminum loaf pans on hand for when I am making more quick breads, banana, zucchini, mango, and persimmon breads usually than I have enough loaf pans to bake them all at once.

Pro Tip: Whenever using disposable aluminum loaf pans, I always set them on a baking sheet before sliding them into the oven. The baking sheet gives them more stability, and they bake very well that way.

2. For Messy Jobs

Disposable aluminum pans are worth their weight in gold when used for marinating foods like meat and vegetables and for baking messy dishes like lasagna or baked beans. The beauty of this use is that they can be tossed into the trash without washing if the cleanup job is overwhelming or if you happen to be short on time.

The pan used to make that cornbread dressing for Thanksgiving dinner is another challenge to clean, so baking the dressing in a disposable pan eliminates that chore.

3. For Transporting Cooked Food

There have been many times in the past when I wished I had taken my contribution to a pot-luck meal in a disposable pan. On one occasion, I lost a perfectly good stainless steel baking pan because another guest thought it was theirs and made off with it when the meal was over. On yet another occasion, I made it home with my Tupperware container, but the top that was with it isn’t mine, and it just doesn’t fit. So, for quite a few years now, I always take my food in containers so that I don’t have to be concerned about getting them back home.

4. For Baking Extra And Freezing A Portion

Quite often when I am making a dish that I just do not make very often because of the long prep time involved, and I am thinking of cornbread dressing while writing this, I usually make a double batch and then bake the two batches separately so that one can be frozen for later. 

The second batch is usually baked in a disposable aluminum pan so I can simply cover it with heavy foil and freeze it to enjoy in a few weeks. In fact, I usually take the aluminum pan out of the oven when it is thoroughly done but just not quite browned yet, so that it will not be overcooked when I reheat it.

5. For Gifts

One of my favorite gift ideas is home-baked goods like quick breads and brownies. These are easily baked in disposable aluminum pans so that I do not have to repackage them. Many of the disposable pans come with lids, so all I have to add is a bow and the gift is all set.

Advantages Of Using Disposable Aluminum Pans

There are many advantages to using disposable aluminum pans. Here are a few:

• They are a great asset to have on hand for those times when you are baking more items than normal, and you do not have enough baking pans for the job that you are undertaking.
• They perform multiple tasks when needed, such as baking a casserole, transporting that casserole to a pot-luck meal, serving in the same container, and then simply discarding that container when it is empty.
• They come in multiple sizes and shapes to cover just about any job you need them for.
• The lightweight aluminum pans are relatively inexpensive.
• The aluminum pans stack well and are easy to store.
• They serve us well when performing messy jobs such as making lasagna or baked beans or using them for marinating meats and vegetables, after which they can simply be discarded.
• They are especially handy when gifting baked goods and transporting leftovers.
• They can be used to freeze various foods, especially casseroles.
• Aluminum pans can be recycled.

Disadvantages Of Using Disposable Aluminum Pans

Even though there are more advantages to using disposable aluminum pans, there are a few disadvantages:

• Disposable aluminum pans are often harder to clean than standard pans and are damaged easily.
• Large disposable aluminum pans are often hard to move around while filled with hot food because they do tend to bend or crack easily, causing the food to spill.
• Even though disposable aluminum pans can be recycled, they are not as environmentally friendly as standard pans because they are limited in the number of times they can be used before becoming damaged.

Final Thoughts

If you check my kitchen cabinets, you are sure to find a supply of disposable aluminum pans that I keep on hand for any time they are needed. I use them often around the holidays for gifting homemade goodies and to use once all my “real” pans are in use.

My favorites, and the ones more frequently used in my kitchen, are the loaf pans, the 8 or 9-inch square pans, and the oblong baking pans for that occasional pan of lasagna I like to take to pot-luck meals.

Thanks for stoppin’ by!

Jelly Grandma

For more, don’t miss The 3 Best Non-Stick Ceramic Pans That Pro Chefs Love.

Anne James

Hi, I’m Anne but my grandchildren call me Jelly Grandma. I have over 50 years of experience as a Southern cook and am a retired librarian. I love sharing what I have learned. You can find me on YouTube as well! Just click the link at the bottom of your page.

Can you bake a cake in a disposable aluminum pan?

What temperature do you bake a cake in a foil pan?